Brief Thought on "Amy's Choice"

[sdelmonte]

This is as close as we are likely to get to the Valeyard. I approve.

Comments

[sdelmonte]

It doesn't feel Moffetty to have the Doctor go that far to the dark side. I think also that there would be reluctance to move in that direction completely because of how much a lot of fans would rather forget "Trial of a Time Lord." (Some fans. I liked that arc.)

[mic-soldier.livejournal.com]

Really? It is a bit rubbish to ignore that, it was one of the best explorations of his characterization as a whole!

(Ah, um, yes, I am a Milliwayser and saw your journal on a friends page, I hope it is okay to comment).

[mabfan.livejournal.com]

I was never that fond of Trial of a Time Lord, but I am a stickler for continuity. When it comes time for the twelfth doctor to regenerate into the thirteenth, I very much hope that the show-runners deal with the Valeyard question.

[badninja.livejournal.com]

That's exactly the problem I think, in a lot of series, whether or not unfavoured continuity still affects or not. Comics get retcon leeway on that. *g*