Unpopular Opinion Time - Sherlock

[sdelmonte]

I finally saw the premiere of the new BBC Sherlock series.

I didn't care for it much. It has a lot going for it, but I did not like Sherlock himself at all. And I have other qualms as well.

From my brief research on the topic, I am the only person on Earth who didn't like it.

This is not the first time I was part of a small minority on such matters. And now I wonder if should either blog more about such matters, or poll my f-list to see who else has that one (or, in case, more than one) thing that just don't get.

That is all.

Comments

[autographedcat.livejournal.com]

While I loved it tremendously, I do want to drop a note saying "Yes, please absolutely expand on your contrary opinions."

I LIKE contrary opinions -- even ones I disagree with. I learn things from them, and get a better handle on my own opinions from the challenge. And you always write well and reasonably enough for this to happen.

[sdelmonte]

Well, if I am to expand, I have three major areas of contention.

The most overwhelming is, as noted, Holmes' sheer unlikeability. I give Cumberbatch a lot of credit for playing it well, but I never felt like this was a hero I wanted to spend any time with. It's not the first time I've seen that - TBH, Bruce Wayne in the batsuit can be just as much of a jerk but only in print - and it's not the first time I have been unsatisfied. Even Monk, a show I liked, tended to shove me away in a similar fashion.

I also was very put off by the visualizations of how Holmes' mind works. He tells us what he found anyway, so it struck me as unnecessary as well. (I didn't quite care for similar tricks in the recent film, either.)

Lastly, once Holmes chose to go with the cabbie and be all cryptic-crazy, the story lost me. It was true to the character as written but not very believable. It worked for me only insofar as it did give us lots of good stuff with Watson. And Martin Freeman, whatever else, was amazing.